New Hartford's Trusted Agency

Your Future Is Protected Before You Even Ask

At Shaffer Insurance Agency, we don't just sell policies — we build lasting relationships grounded in trust, local expertise, and a genuine commitment to your peace of mind.

Get Your Free Quote Explore Services
30+
Years of Service
100%
Local & Independent
5
Insurance Carriers
What We Offer

Comprehensive Coverage
For Every Chapter of Life

From your first home to your growing business, we provide tailored insurance solutions that evolve with you.

Homeowners Insurance

Protect what matters most with comprehensive coverage for your home, belongings, and personal liability — tailored to New Hartford's unique needs.

Auto Insurance

Whether it's your daily commute or a weekend road trip, we ensure you're covered on the road with competitive rates and reliable claims support.

Life Insurance

Secure your family's financial future with term, whole, or universal life policies designed to give you confidence no matter what tomorrow brings.

Business Insurance

From startup to established enterprise, we craft commercial policies that shield your business from risk so you can focus on growth.

Umbrella Policies

Extra liability protection beyond your standard policies — because sometimes the unexpected requires an extra layer of security.

Risk Consultation

Not sure what you need? We analyze your unique situation and recommend the right coverage — no pressure, no jargon, just honest advice.

Shaffer Insurance Agency office in New Hartford
About Us

A Neighbor You Can Trust With What Matters Most

Shaffer Insurance Agency has been a cornerstone of the New Hartford community for over three decades. We believe insurance isn't about paperwork — it's about people. When disaster strikes, you need someone who answers the phone, understands your story, and fights for your claim.

As an independent agency, we work with multiple top-rated carriers to find the right fit for your needs and budget. No one-size-fits-all solutions here — just honest, personalized guidance from people who live and work right here in your community.

Locally Owned & Operated
Multiple Carrier Options
Personal Claims Advocacy
No Obligation Reviews
Schedule a Consultation
Our Process

Simple Steps to Total Confidence

We've streamlined the insurance process so you can get protected without the hassle.

01

Tell Us Your Story

Share what you're looking to protect — your home, your vehicle, your business, or your family's future. We listen first.

02

We Find Your Match

Our team shops multiple carriers to compare coverage and pricing, presenting you with clear, honest recommendations.

03

You Drive With Confidence

Once covered, you have a dedicated local agent you can call anytime — not a 1-800 number or a chatbot.

Shaffer Insurance has been our family's trusted advisor for over a decade. They've guided us through every life change — buying our first home, adding a car, starting a business — always with patience and integrity.

— A Valued Client Since 2012

Get Started Today

Let's Build Your Protection Plan Together

Reach out for a no-obligation consultation. We'll review your current coverage, identify gaps, and recommend solutions that actually make sense for your situation.

Request a Free Quote
(315) 735-0433
5 Chestnut Rd, New Hartford, NY 13413
Contact Us

Send Us a Message

Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you within one business day.

Message Sent!

Thank you for reaching out. We'll be in touch within one business day.

Is this your business?This is my business